I
VERDICT OF HISTORY
1
The Case for Equity
Historical Facts and Media Fiction
The “new-era” doctrine—that “good” stocks (or blue
chips) were sound investments regardless of how
high the price paid for them—was at the bottom only
a means of rationalizing under the title of
“investment” the well-nigh universal capitulation to
the gambling fever.
—Benjamin Graham and David
Dodd, 1934
Investing in stocks has become a national hobby and
a national obsession. To update Marx, it is the religion
of the masses.
—Roger Lowenstein, 1996
Stocks for the Long Run by Siegel? Yeah, all it’s good
for now is a doorstop.
—Comment from
caller on CNBC,
March 2009, at
the bottom of the
worst bear market
in 80 years
“EVERYBODY OUGHT TO BE RICH”
In the summer of 1929, a journalist named Samuel Crowther
interviewed John J. Raskob, a senior financial executive at
General Motors, about how the typical individual could build
wealth by investing in stocks. In August of that year,
Crowther published Raskob’s ideas in a Ladies’ Home
Journal article with the audacious title “Everybody Ought to
Be Rich.”
In the interview, Raskob claimed that America was on the
verge of a tremendous industrial expansion. He maintained
that by putting just $15 per month into good common
stocks, investors could expect their wealth to grow steadily
to $80,000 over the next 20 years. Such a return—24
percent per year—was unprecedented, but the prospect of
effortlessly amassing a great fortune seemed plausible in
the atmosphere of the 1920s bull market. Stocks excited
investors, and millions put their savings into the market
seeking quick profit.
On September 3, 1929, a few days after Raskob’s advice
appeared, the Dow Jones Industrial Average hit a historic
high of 381.17. Seven weeks later, stocks crashed. The next
34 months saw the most devastating decline in share values
in US history.
On July 8, 1932, when the carnage was finally over, the
Dow Industrials stood at 41.22. The market value of the
world’s greatest corporations had declined an incredible 89
percent. Millions of investors’ life savings were wiped out,
and thousands of investors who had borrowed money to buy
stocks were forced into bankruptcy. America was mired in
the deepest economic depression in its history.
Raskob’s advice was ridiculed and denounced for years
to come. It was said to represent the insanity of those who
believed that the market could rise forever and the
foolishness of those who ignored the tremendous risks in