Opportunities in Private Equity by Alper Daglioglu, Al Troianello, Rafique Decastro, Lane Decordova
The Rise in Private Equity
While private equity has been a source of investment capital for
decades, it is still considered a boutique investment category,
representing only 2.5% of the global invested capital market. 1 In
the early days, the private equity universe was limited to a select
few venture capital or buyout funds, often located primarily on the
West Coast or the Northeast. Today, awareness of private equity
has increased and it has become an investment class that is
accepted and commonly used by many institutional plans.
The private equity industry is now a large, global and
developed industry. Its popularity is evident in the growth in PE
assets under management (AUM), which combines the amount
invested in private equity and the amount of new funds committed
to future private equity investments. As illustrated in Exhibit 1, in
the last 15 years alone, private equity AUM have grown almost
five times to a record $2.4 trillion as of December 2015. 2
Along with other alternative investments, the private equity
industry has evolved to include a variety of strategies and as a
result now appeals to a greater variety of investors. Investors can
access PE directly through venture capital or buyout funds, or a
hybrid of both, such as co-investment vehicles or secondary
vehicles.
Types of Strategies
Some of the most common private equity strategies are outlined
below:
Buyout. Buyouts, or leveraged buyouts (LBO), are equity
investments to acquire a controlling interest in a company,
typically with the use of financial leverage, and are usually
categorized from small/mid to large/mega capital funds. Investors
in buyout strategies are interested in more mature companies with
demonstrated cash flow, making the four primary drivers of
buyout returns earnings, earnings multiple, debt and time. Most
importantly, a buyout will invariably involve the use of debt.
Indeed, today’s financial engineering solutions for buyouts will
often involve various layers of debt, ranging from straight senior
debt secured by the company’s assets to pure cash flow lending
with equity kickers, what’s known as mezzanine financing. Debt
plays a key role in the generation of buyout returns, operating to
enhance equity returns. Buyouts can be distinguished from our
next strategy, venture capital, in a number of ways. Chief among
these are that buyouts generally focus on established companies
rather than young businesses and the fact that buyouts use debt as
well as equity financing (and frequently combinations of the two).
Another apparent distinction is between “control” and
“noncontrol” investing. In control investing, the private equity
manager either owns a majority of the shares in the company or at
least has control over the majority of the voting rights.
Venture Capital. Venture capital generally means an
investment in a company prior to an initial public offering, and
often early in the company's life cycle. Venture investments are
most often found in the application of new technology, new
marketing concepts and new products with an unproven track
record or lack of a stable revenue stream. Venture capital is often
subdivided by the stage of development of the company, ranging
from early-stage capital used for the launch of start-up companies
to late-stage and growth capital that is often used to fund
expansion of an existing business that generates revenue but may
not yet be profitable or generating cash flow to fund future growth.
Venture deals, unlike buyout deals for the most part, will enjoy
successive rounds of financing, and the point in the company’s
development when each of these rounds occurs will determine
whether such a round is, for example, “early” or “mid.” The basic
drivers of a venture fund’s returns are the post-money valuation of
the rounds and the percentage of the company’s equity which a
fund holds. By far the most important measure of venture
performance is the money multiple, i.e., the ratio of the total
amount of cash generated by an investment to the total amount of
cash invested. The internal rate of return (IRR) is also important,
but is largely meaningless in the early to mid-stages of a fund
given the longer average holding periods of venture funds. We
discuss private equity performance in a later section.
Growth Capital. Growth capital is an investment in more
mature companies to provide funding for growth and expansion.
Growth capital is usually provided to later-stage companies with
products and services that are already generating significant
revenue. Companies that seek growth capital will often do so in
order to finance transformative events in their life cycle.
Distressed and Special Situations. Distressed private equity
strategies look at companies experiencing financial stress that
appear to be poised for a possible turnaround. A substrategy for
distressed investing is “distressed-for-control,” which involves
investors acquiring debt securities in the hopes of emerging from a
corporate restructuring in control of the company’s equity. Special
situation strategies are seeking undercapitalized segments of niche
markets where private equity capital can exploit opportunities.
Special situation strategies are also referred to as “turnaround”
strategies where an investor will provide debt and equity
investments, often in the form of rescue financing, to companies
undergoing operational or financial challenges.
Secondaries and Co-Investments. Secondary fund
opportunities involve acquiring direct interests of primary funds
from existing limited partners, usually at a discount to the
portfolio’s net asset value. Secondary investments provide
institutional investors, particularly those new to private equity,
with the ability to improve vintage year, sector and geographical
diversification. Secondaries also typically experience a different
cash-flow profile, diminishing the J-curve effect of investing in
new private equity funds (Exhibit 4, see page 5). Often
investments in secondaries are made through a third-party fund
vehicle, structured similarly to a fund of funds although many
large institutional investors have purchased private equity fund
interests through secondary transactions. Co-investment
opportunities involve investing alongside general partners in
individual deals. They typically are offered to preferred existing
limited partners in the fund on a no-fee and no-carry basis. Co-
investments are usually prevalent in a market environment where
debt financing is difficult to obtain or prohibitively expensive, or
where general partners are limited by portfolio constraints on
single investments in their fund, and have to partner to meet equity
requirements.
Other Strategies. There are numerous other strategies that can
be considered private equity. These strategies include real estate,
infrastructure, energy and royalty-fund investing. Real estate in the
context of private equity will typically refer to the riskier end of
the investment spectrum including “value-added” or
“opportunistic” funds where the investments often more closely
resemble buyouts than traditional “core” real estate investments.
Infrastructure investments are in various public projects, typically
made as part of a privatization initiative. Energy investments are in
a wide variety of companies engaged in the production and sale of
energy. Additionally, royalty investments purchase a consistent
revenue stream deriving from the payment of royalties.
Private Equity Life Cycle and
Performance
Private equity fund managers have four principal roles: raise
funds from investors, source investment opportunities, select the
most appropriate investments, and actively manage and realize
capital gains by monetizing these investments. Remember, these
events can vary depending on the strategy but each stage typically
occurs in a company’s life cycle (Exhibit 2, see page 4).
Private equity funds differ in strategy, structure, and objective
compared to more traditional investment funds. For one, private
equity funds are unlike any other form of investment in that they
represent a stream of unpredictable cash flows over the life of the
fund, both inward and outward. These cash flows are
unpredictable not only as to their amount, but also as to their
timing. The life cycle stage of the private equity investment is
pivotal for deciding which strategy to put into place.
The private equity life cycle begins with investors, or the
limited partner (LP), making a capital commitment to a fund. Once
a fund is closed to new commitments, the general partner (GP)
Opportunities in Private Equity by Alper Daglioglu, Al Troianello, Rafique Decastro, Lane Decordova