Compendium – Cryptocurrency regulations by country
Cryptocurrency regulations by country
June 1, 2021
By Todd Ehret and Susannah Hammond, Regulatory Intelligence
The public appetite and enthusiasm for cryptocurrencies such
as bitcoin have exploded in recent years. First introduced in
2008 as an alternative and disruptive technology to traditional
banking and payments, bitcoin and other digital currencies
or digital assets were met with skepticism and caution
as they were not understood. Their anonymity also made
cryptocurrencies susceptible to misuse in illicit activities.
Much has changed in recent years, as the number of users
has exploded, and some established financial services
firms have also begun to test the crypto waters. Prices
have rocketed despite incredible volatility, and financial
regulators and regulations have struggled to keep pace.
The regulatory regime surrounding cryptocurrencies is
fragmented and stretches to the extremes of outright bans
in some jurisdictions, to some countries that are advocates.
Complete restrictions are somewhat rare and difficult to enforce,
with crypto markets regularly shrugging off news of restrictions
in some jurisdictions, but regulators are scrambling to clarify
rules and keep pace with crypto’s exploding popularity.
The regulatory overlay related to digital assets such as bitcoin
and other cryptocurrencies in its infancy, and the challenge of
building a regulatory framework often is complex and uncertain.
Many market participants insist on a more established
regulatory regime and certainty, which likely means new
rules, regulations, or at a minimum official guidance. The
race to create such a regulatory regime is now underway.
Crypto-assets, cryptocurrencies, central bank digital
currencies and non-fungible tokens make up the new “crypto”
universe, and each provides unique benefits, challenges,
and complexities. This annex provides a country-by-country
summary of the cryptocurrency regulatory picture. The list
below focuses on cryptocurrencies such as bitcoin. It provides
an overview for each country, the regulatory state of play
and links to the primary financial regulatory authorities or
relevant documents. Much of the regulatory framework is still
developing, and regulations and restrictions also vary greatly
depending on uses such as payments, investments, derivatives,
and tax status. Most countries have generally found ways to tax
gains or income derived from cryptocurrencies, and some have
more specific obligations than others. Few pure “tax havens”
remain.
Regulatory Intelligence may delve deeper into other aspects
of cryptos such as non-fungible tokens and digital central
bank currencies in future articles or special reports.
North America
Canada – Canada has been an early adopter and is seen
as quite “crypto-friendly” with several approvals of bitcoin
exchange-traded funds (ETFs). Canadian Securities
Administrators (CSA) and the Investment Industry Regulatory
Organization of Canada (IIROC) have issued guidance requiring
crypto trading platforms and dealers in Canada to register with
the local provincial regulators. Firms dealing with cryptos are
considered money service businesses (MSBs) and must also
register with the Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis
Centre of Canada (FINTRAC). The requirements also apply to
foreign-based firms if they have Canadian customers.
The Canada Revenue Authority (CRA) generally treats
cryptocurrency like a commodity for purposes of the Income Tax
Act.
Mexico – Mexico has embraced cryptocurrencies and is seen
as a very crypto-friendly jurisdiction. The Mexican government
and the financial authority, CNBV enacted a new set of fintech
laws in March 2018. Its largest crypto exchange, Bitsos, has
more than 1 million users on its platform.
Mexico’s Federal AML Law was amended in March 2018 to
include transactions with “virtual assets”.
Mexico’s tax framework for cryptocurrencies is expected to
change as there is no official position. Most see cryptos as
intangible assets where gains would be taxed at 30% for
corporations and anywhere from 2% to 35% for individuals.
United States – The regulatory framework for
cryptocurrencies is evolving despite overlap and differences
in viewpoints between agencies. Although the Securities and
Exchange Commission is widely seen as the most powerful
regulator, Treasury’s FinCEN, the Federal Reserve Board, and
the CFTC have issued their own differing interpretations and
guidance. The SEC often views cryptos as securities, the CFTC
calls bitcoin a commodity, and Treasury calls it a currency. The
Internal Revenue Service (IRS) defines cryptocurrencies as “a
digital representation of value that functions as a medium of
exchange, a unit of account, and/or a store of value” and has
issued tax guidance accordingly.
Despite the muddied regulatory framework, the United States
is seen as home to the largest number of crypto investors,
exchanges, trading platforms, crypto mining firms and
investment funds.
Central and South America
Argentina – In Argentina, investing in cryptocurrencies is
legal but they are not considered legal currency or tender
as they are not issued by the government. Although there
are no regulations, profits are taxable. Legislation has
been proposed to create a national legal and regulatory
framework for crypto-assets as a means of payments,
investments, and transactions.
The Argentina Securities and Exchange Commission (CNV)
will be the regulatory body with oversight responsibilities
and plans to maintain a national registry of operations with
transactions reported to the Financial Information Unit (FIU)
for compliance with anti-money laundering requirements.
Argentina’s Federal Administration of Public Income (AFIP)
and central bank have requested more information from
domestic crypto exchanges and banks. Gains from cryptos
are generally taxable at a 4% to 6.5% rate on gross income
for each digital currency transaction.
Bolivia – The Bolivian government banned the use of
cryptocurrencies such as bitcoin in 2014, in the belief that
it would facilitate tax evasion and monetary instability.
“It is illegal to use any kind of currency that is not issued
and controlled by a government or an authorized entity,”
Bolivia’s central bank (BCB) said.
Brazil – Cryptocurrencies in Brazil are largely unregulated.
Legislators have, however, begun to propose a series of
regulations that might fill the void if enacted. The Brazilian
Securities and Exchange Commission, or CVM has approved
two crypto ETFs. The Brazilian government has declared
that bitcoin is an asset and therefore is subject to capital
gains taxes. Brazil has said that existing AML laws extend
to virtual currencies in a few contexts.
The Special Department of Federal Revenue of Brazil has
published a document on cryptocurrency taxes in the country.
Chile – The Chilean government has committed to develop
a regulatory and oversight framework for cryptocurrencies
and the growing number of cryptocurrency exchanges in the
country. In the absence of a legal framework, the Central
Bank and the Financial Market Commission has said that
existing regulations are applicable to cryptocurrencies.
The Chilean Internal Revenue Service (SII) is the
only institution so far to have issued legislation on
cryptocurrencies in Notice no 963, issued on May 14, 2018.
The SII released a determination on the taxation of income
obtained from buying and selling cryptocurrencies. It said
that Tax Form 22 would require the declaration “from the
sale of foreign currencies of legal course or assets digital/
virtual, such as cryptocurrencies (for example, bitcoins)”.
Colombia – In Colombia there is no specific legislation
regulating the use of cryptocurrencies. The Banco de
la República, the country’s monetary, exchange and
credit authority, and the Superintendencia Financiera
de Colombia (SFC), the government agency responsible
for overseeing financial regulation and market systems,
released statements on cryptos warning they are not legal
tender or valid investments for supervised entities, and
firms are not authorized to advise or manage them
Compendium – Cryptocurrency regulations by country Cry Author Todd Ehret and Susannah Hammond